This is part of one of the online trees for a relative of mine. I’ve eliminated the name and the precise date of birth because I’m more interested in how Ancestry.com handles citing sources than who this specific individual is whose birth is being cited. I’ve also seen problems like this countless times so I don’t want to appear to be picking on this entry only.
I’ve see all six “sources” used in this instance. The Ancestry.com tree indicates that all six are sources for the fact that this person was born on a certain date in a certain place. The problem is that all six sources do not say that. Tying these sources to a precise date and place of birth is indicating that they are more accurate than they really are.
- The 1900 census provides a month and year of birth along with the state.
- The 1920 and 1930 census provides an age and a place of birth. The age does not necessarily suggest a specific date–which this citation seems to indicate that it does.
- The death index does provide the date and place of birth.
- The U. S. National Home for the Disabled Volunteer Soldiers provides an approximate year of birth and a state of birth.
- The World War I draft card provides a county and state of birth along with a date of birth.
Why not just link them all to the precise date and place? After all, that’s a heck of a lot easier. It may be, but it’s a heck of a lot less accurate.
There’s only 1 of the six records that provide the specific location and date–so really only one should be listed as a source with that precise information.
Indicating a record says something it does not is confusing and in this case it looks like there are more sources with that level of detail than there are.
The date and place for an event when tied to a source for that should only be as precise as that source indicates.
Sure it takes a little more work, but it makes our work more accurate and makes analysis easier.
- Month and year in Illinois should be tied to 1900 census.
- Approximate year and location of Illinois should be tied to the 1930 census and Soldier’s Home information.
- The approximate year and county and state should be tied to the draft card.
- Specific date and specific place should be tied to the death index.