[note: This post originally appeared on our old blog site on 29 August 2013 and is being reprinted.]
Genealogy is not a mad rush towards Charlemagne. It is a slow path, filled with frontier brush, Southern sweat, and New England winters. Instead of leading to castles and mansions, that path often leads to one-room cabins, coal miner’s shacks, and urban tenements. And it leads to the people who made the fabric of this nation, either by harvesting it in the fields, weaving it in the mills, selling it the general store, or saving to earn the money to purchase it.
And that’s just fine with me.
The obsession with celebrity leads some to ask “what famous person am I related to?” or “what celebrity is my umpteenth cousin?”
The obsession with research leads others to ask :who were my great-grandparents?” What impacted their lives? What historical events beyond their control shaped them in ways that I can’t really imagine? And what records did those people leave behind to give me some glimpse into their lives?
 |
| Ralph, Nellie, and Cecil Neill–about 1911–near Stillwell, St. Albans Township, Hancock County, Illinois–probably taken on whatever farm Charlie Neill (their father) was renting. The author’s grandfather is on the right. |
Not in an Instant
The search for those records can take a lifetime, even in the era of the internet. It’s not just about the search for some obscure document that makes a connection or finding as much material as possible. Genealogy is not the accumulation of capital. It is about stitching documents together, fleshing out the unwritten clues in the records, and weaving the written and the unwritten together into a story that is based upon sound research, sound methodology and yet is engaging to the reader. The difficulty for those who strive to accurately document their heritage is that many of those who lived their lives outside the bright glow of fame do not always leave the amount of records that makes telling their story easy.
 |
| Family of George and Ida (Sargent) Trautvetter, taken approximately 1920. The family was living in the vicinity of Tioga and Loraine, Illinois.The author’s grandmother is on the far right. |
Accuracy Matters
Family history research is about being as accurate as possible–not so much because that’s the right way to do it (which it is), but because telling our ancestors’ stories accurately honors their lives. Sloppy and hasty research, thirty-second conclusions, and mere data collection with the intent of “getting as much as we can and as far back as we can” does a disservice to those who came before us, even the ancestors whose lives are ones we may choose not to emulate. Would we not want our own stories told as accurately as possible? Would you want someone in one hundred years confusing you with your deadbeat cousin of the same name whose never worked a day in his life, been arrested more times than he has fingers and has children with women in three different time zones?
 |
| Alvin, Leroy and John H. Ufkes–taken on Fred Ufkes farm east of Basco, Hancock County, Illinois, probably late 1930s The author’s grandfather is on the right. |
Let’s Be Royal
Some researchers desire to make that royal connection and establish their family tree back to the ancient royal houses of Europer. That’s never been my interest. My interest is in making connections that are as accurate as possible. Does that mean I have a few relatives born in the 1840s that are my “brick walls” and for whom I may never find out much more? Yes.
Oh Darn. They Were All Farmers
I hear people lamenting their “farming” ancestors and how their ancestors are all boring, etc. To adequately research my farming ancestors, I have had to learn about state and federal laws, historical trends, migration patterns, women’s rights, agricultural practices, naming patterns, sociological trends, and historical details for more locations than I can count. Sometimes I’m glad my ancestors are all somewhat homogeneous as it cuts the learning curve.
Will your descendants think you, your occupation and your lifestyle are boring and not worthy of any study at all?
There are no boring ancestors–just researchers who’ve not yet gone beneath the surface.
3 Responses
This sad little lizard told me that he was a brontosaurus on his
mother’s side. I did not laugh; people who boast of ancestry often have
little else to sustain them. Humoring them costs nothing and adds to
happiness in a world in which happiness is always in short supply.
— Lazarus Long, from Robert A. Heinlein’s “Time Enough For Love”
I saw someone claim to be descended from Boudicca (d 60/61 AD), of all people! I asked them how, because to the best of my knowledge, no one knows what happened to her daughters, and I was genuinely curious. Of course, I got no answer.
Love your first paragraph, by the way!
Excellent Michael! What a great refresher to keep us on our toes and on course. I too enjoyed your first paragraph but especially appreciated your focus on accuracy.
The majority of my ancestors were farmers. Hard working and honorable profession, ecking out a living from the soil. A few have made me scratch my head and a few give all the appearances of having vanished. All in all it makes for challenging detective work. And have always been drawn to a good mystery. :0}
I like to find royal ancestors because much is already known of their lives. I can even see pictures of some of the everyday things that I know they would have touched. This isn’t the case with most of my more recent ancestors. I work hard to try to find the stories of my more recent ancestors, and bless those who are telling the stories of the royals.